Background image

terug

Cause for concern in the party ranks

Cause for concern in the party ranks

11     John Carlisle is the sort of man you might just notice in an empty room. He is the
2 sitting member of parliament for Luton North and, without wishing to be rude to Luton
3 North, is the perfect chap for the job. For if his constituency were to be somehow made
4 flesh it would walk around looking very much like John Russell Carlisle.
25     This is an obvious disadvantage for a member of a ruling party which has a surfeit
6 of smart grey suits and blue ties in its ranks. An MP must make his mark: he must catch
7 the eye of the speaker, of the government, of the party managers and of the press. If you
8 are simply the leader of Luton’s Conservatives, it is not easy.
39     The common solution to the problem, which Carlisle has grabbed with a rare
10 enthusiasm, is monomania, the obsession with a single idea or interest. The member must
11 then talk about it until his gizzard goes grey. In the case of Geoffrey Dickens MP it is
12 paedophilia, with Tam Dalyell it is battleships of a foreign flag and in Clare Short's case
13 it is pornography. For John Carlisle the idée fixe is sport and polities.
414     Carlisle had a false start in choosing his obsession. In 1981 he launched a political
15 campaign of the most devastating order against East European vacuum cleaners which
16 he felt were competing unfairly in British markets. He may have had a point, but he also
17 had the good sense to perceive that vacuum cleaners were not an issue of moment. So he
18 moved on to his latest fixation, a subject which could not be more topical or, if you prefer,
19 a topic which could not be more subjective.
520     Carlisle, 44, believes that all sporting links with South Africa should be reinstated
21 and that in general sport and politics should not be associated with each other. This view
22 does not go down well in Britain's universities and Carlisle has been pelted, kicked and
23 jostled on campuses as far apart as Oxford and Bradford. His argument is this: what on
24 earth does a Test match with South Africa have to do with apartheid? And why does the
25 Commonwealth have to suffer because of Britain's failure to implement sanctions?
626     During our conversation last week a familiar inconsistency emerged. He produced
27 the rusty idea that sportsmen convert each other and are really propagandists for
28 tolerance. 'H's much better to keep channels open', he said. "The athletes meet and talk
29 and exchange ideas.' Surely this is politics entering sport and should thus be condemned.
730     Anyway, I have never believed this business of sportsmen converting each other.
31 Here are two rugby players conversing as they scrum down in the manner that Carlisle
32 must imagine:
833     'Hi, Pieter. I'm Roger. I wonder if you’ve ever thought about our democracy. H's
34 really very good coz everyone has a vote and you get to say what you want without being
35 bullwhipped by the special police.'
936     'Well, Roger. You've really got a point there, I'll have a word with PW1) when I'm
37 next in Pretoria.'
1038     Oddly Carlisle did support the boycott of the Moscow Olympic Games, so his
39 passion for sport is not always the priority.
1140     Although he insists apartheid is bad, he appears to take a lenient attitude towards
41 South Africa. He maintains his own dialogue with the South African embassy in London.
42 He is secretary of the British South Africa Society and he often visits the country in
43 pursuit of his ideas. One trip has been paid for by the South Africans. Even for Mrs
44 Thatcher, Carlisle must still be an embarrassment.
 
     Henry Porter in The Sunday Times, July 27, 1986
noot 1: PW: P.W. Botha, Prime Minister of South Africa in 1986