Background image

terug

Gentle touch at school of hard knocks

In the following text Barry Hugill reports on Gordonstoun, a public school in the north of Scotland. In a recent interview Prince Charles revealed that he hated every minute of his stay there.

11    The founder called it 'Platonie'; the present he ad prefers 'Hahnian', Both mean the
2 sort of education on offer at Gordonstoun. Seventeen-year-old William puts it more
3 simply: 'Being here means you spend weekends up mountains buried in snow ... it's a hell
4 of an experience.'
25    When not up to his neck in snow, he is on compulsory sea rescue duty or 'serving the
6 community' in a wide range of demanding ways. Gordonstoun is a public school in the
7 north of Scotland - a fact known to almost the en tire population of the UK and much of
8 the rest of the world, because last week Prince Charles revealed that he cried himself to
9 sleep at night th ere, driven to despair by bullies.
310    The school does its best to show its caring side. Mark Pyper, the head, insists that
11 times have changed: 'Some of the more vigorous physical activities have gone . .. but we
12 have not gone soft. And we are certainly not soft on bullying - we have expelled people for
13 it .' His words could be seen as an attempt to limit the damage done to Gordonstoun's
14 reputation.
415    Kurt Hahn, a German lew, fled Hitier in 1934 and set up the school. Taking his lead
16 from the Greek philosopher Plato, he pushed children to the limits of their physical
17 capacities so they could discover themselves.
518    Mr Pyper says the philosophy remains essentially the same, although more stress is
19 now placed on the academie - most pupils get good A-levels and go on to university. But
20 you cannot visit Gordonstoun without being struck by the physical. if it's not mountains,
21 it 's the sea and the rugby, running, tennis, climbing, swimming, soccer and almost any other
22 sport you care to mention. And this is north-east Scotland, where the wind tears at the
23 innards and the skies are grey for weeks on end.
624    Discovering yourself does not come cheap - f12,000 a year, although the school
25 prides itself on a scholarship scheme for poorer families. For the cash , pupils experience
26 what Hahn called the 'moral equivalent of war'.
727    This sounds rather militaristic, but Mr Pyper doesn't see it that way: 'It means that
28 the pupils learn to serve the community with the same heroism and commitment th at
29 soldiers need to show in a war'.
830    It also sounds quite brutal. Same of the school's 453 pupils must be unhappy
31 freezing on top of a mountain. 'Of course, some don't want to go. But 1 can guarantee they
32 all come back having had the time of their lives,' says Mr Pyper.
933    We spoke to about 15 pupils, all of whom were happy and said that the mountain
34 expeditions and seamanship had done them good. This is 17-year-old Emma: '1 was
35 terrified at the prospect of the boats . . . but once I started, 1 loved it. Maybe the only way
36 to find out is to be told to do it.'
1037    Or William: 'You don't want to spend a weekend up a mountain in the snow. But you
38 are glad later, and you wouldn't have done it otherwise.'
1139    They insisted that smoking does not take place and denied illicit drug taking. Bath
40 activities are banned. Gordonstoun places great emphasis on trust - teachers don't enforce
41 rules, but trust pupils to follow them. Yet the biggest growth rate in smoking nationally is
42 among teenage girls, of whom there are more than 200 at Gordonstoun. Either the pupils
43 are not telling the truth or they are amazingly obedient.
1244    Evidence that the latter might be the case should be seen in the uniform. Many
45 schools have uniforms but pupils almost always get round it. But not at Gordonstoun.
46 Many parents will say that alone makes it worth paying f12,OOO a year.
1347    The Gordonstoun board is studying a plan to widen the intake and allow 'more
48 young people from underprivileged backgrounds to benefit from a Gordonstoun
49 education'. But two children will not be enrolling. Prince Charles is determined th at his
50 sons should escape the Hahnian experience - he wants them to go to Eton, where the
51 mountains are few and the snow infrequent.

The Observer', October 23,1994